Apple Identifies Which Samsung Products It Will Try To Ban In US

With the trial stage just completed last Friday, Apple wasted no time filing a notice with the court identifying which Samsung products it will now seek to have banned in the US. Despite having received a finding of infringement from the jury on most of the 28 products in play in the case, it looks like Apple is only going after an injunction on eight of them — all smartphones. That’s not terribly surprising given the fact that many of the products in the case are no longer available in the US. The eight Samsung devices are:

  • Galaxy S 4G
  • Galaxy S2 (AT&T)
  • Galaxy S2 (Skyrocket)
  • Galaxy S2 (T-Mobile)
  • Galaxy S2 Epic 4G
  • Galaxy S Showcase
  • Droid Charge
  • Galaxy Prevail

APPLE WILL STILL HAVE TO PROVE IRREPARABLE HARM BASED ON THESE EIGHT SMARTPHONES

Apple’s filing specifically associates the devices with the patents each was found to infringe according to the jury. You can see from the chart below that, save the Galaxy Prevail, each of the identified devices was found to infringe on Apple’s design-related intellectual property (design patents and trade dress). The Galaxy S2 Skyrocket, Galaxy S2 Epic 4G and the Galaxy S Showcase are the only ones listed that escaped infringement of Apple’s more technical utility patents. With infringement already established, and assuming Judge Koh doesn’t disrupt the jury verdict, Apple must convince the court that it will be irreparably harmed if these handsets are not banned in the country. It’s easier to make this argument after a positive jury verdict, but an injunction is by no means a foregone conclusion. However, Apple did apparently appreciate the benefits of picking its battles here, rather than just going after each and every product found to infringe. It’s easier for Apple to establish irreparable harm when the focus of the injunction is on products it may actually compete against in the market.

You’ll remember that there’s already a preliminary injunction on the Galaxy Tab 10.1 in place, and Samsung has now asked the court to lift that ban based on the fact that the jury didn’t find that its tablets infringed Apple’s design patents. Apple is opposing Samsung’s request and, according to Bloomberg, even wants to extend the ban to the cellular version of the Tab 10.1 — which wasn’t included in the jury’s verdict form. You can see that Judge Koh will have a lot to work through at the injunction hearing currently scheduled for September 20th.

Via: The Verge

More:  San Francisco ChronicleeWeekBloombergGizmodoDroid LifeAndroid News, Rumours …FOSS Patents,CNNMoney.comCNETForbesThe Next WebAndroid and MeWebProNewsTechnoBuffaloReadWriteWebVentureBeatEngadgetTechCrunchReutersPadGadget and MacRumors

Prateek Panda

Prateek is the Founder of TheTechPanda. He's passionate about technology startups and entrepreneurship and enjoys speaking to new founders every day. Prateek has also been consistently regarded as one of the top marketing experts in the region.

Recent Posts

DeepSource’s new autonomous AI agents promise to scan, fix code security vulnerabilities

As artificial intelligence (AI) continues to progress exponentially, the future of industries like software engineering…

13 hours ago

Retail’s Return Rate Crisis: The Urgent Need for Proactive Solutions

The average return rate in eCommerce is estimated at 17.6% for 2024. Nearly 1 in 5 products…

1 day ago

AI Launches: Cybersecurity, AI Agents, product specs, business operating system, automobile, consumer & MSME lending, cloud, data streaming

The Tech Panda takes a look at recent launches in the superfast field of Artificial…

2 days ago

As India’s tech sector on track to surpass $300 billion, CEO of Ness shares insights into AI’s important role 

The tech sector in India has been going from strength to strength in recent years.…

2 days ago

Unknown & uncontrolled machine identities within organizations leading to emergence of new identity security challenges

Experts are saying that organizations are inadvertently creating a new identity-centric attack surface through growing…

2 days ago

Outbound & inbound: India attracts businesses from US & Singapore while expanding to UAE, Europe & Philippines

The Tech Panda takes a look at how India has been attracting foreign businesses from…

3 days ago